Coralis Camacho Garcia came to Florida from hurricane-devastated Puerto Rico. She still had her original documents so she could register to vote — she was one of the lucky ones.
Coralis Camacho Garcia left Puerto Rico almost a year after Hurricane Maria. In July, she moved to Kissimmee, Florida, to find better healthcare for her children.
Voting in the midterm elections wasn’t on the top of her mind — nor did she realize the effort it could take to cast a ballot. Camacho Garcia is one of tens of thousands of people to leave the island for Florida. Many of them have faced a bureaucratic nightmare as they attempt to exercise their right to vote.
Unlike many people arriving from Puerto Rico, Camacho Garcia was lucky enough to have her documents in order.
She still had an official copy of her birth certificate, sufficient to obtain a Florida ID. Many people either lose official documents in disasters or misplace them — and replacing vital records like birth certificates isn’t easy in the aftermath of a disaster like Hurricane Maria.
She was able to obtain state identification and register to vote soon after arriving in Florida through the organization VoteRiders. The nonprofit works to secure identification for voters who lack it in states that require proof of identity to cast a ballot.
Camacho Garcia found out about the organization’s work through a family friend who works registering community members to vote. One trip to the DMV later, she thought she was all set.
“The request rate is so, so high right now,” said Jazlyn Gallejo, the voter ID coalition coordinator at VoteRiders in Florida, who went to the DMV with Camacho Garcia. “It’s incredibly slow.” She explained that the fastest way to get official documents from Puerto Rico to Florida is often to ask someone still on the island to collect official records and send them overnight by FedEx.
“You probably have a lot of other things to deal with besides making sure you have your government-issued photo ID,” said Melissa Michelson, professor of political science at Menlo College. “Even if you want to vote, you’re talking about the huge investment of time and effort to get new copies of those documents.”
Changes in election law, like voter ID requirements, used to be subject to federal clearance under the Voting Rights Act — prior to the Supreme Court decision in Shelby County v. Eric Holder in 2013. Such shifts in standards have a disproportionate impact on communities of color, says Gabriel Sanchez, professor of political science at the University of New Mexico. Sanchez also runs Latino Decisions, a group that conducts political opinion research in Latino communities.
“These laws aren’t supposed to disaffect any one subgroup of the electorate,” he told WhoWhatWhy. “I don’t see how you can make the argument that the folks who have been negatively impacted by the hurricane are not going to be disproportionately impacted [by voter ID requirements].”
Florida does little to streamline the process. Many jurisdictions in the state – and elsewhere — fail to provide translated ballots and election information. District Judge Mark Walker just ruled the practice a violation of federal law, writing in his opinion that “voting in a language you do not understand is like asking this court to decide the winner of the Nobel Prize for Chemistry — ineffective, in other words.”
Moreover, the state issues physical registration cards to each voter. While not necessary to cast a ballot, the card clarifies that a voter is in fact registered and contains basic information like the closest polling place, name, and party affiliation. Three months after filling out the paperwork, Camacho Garcia has yet to receive hers in the mail. She is technically registered, but the uncertainty kept her from the ballot box during the primary election in August.
The confusion serves to keep people from showing up at all. Many voters from historically disenfranchised communities report staying home on Election Day out of fear. “It’s just extra barriers,” said Michelson. “It’s disenfranchising.”
Right now in Florida, that means fewer people may show up to vote on pivotal issues. The November ballot includes an amendment to restore voting rights for people with past felony convictions. The current governor, Rick Scott (R), is running for Senate against Democratic incumbent Bill Nelson.
“Some folks say we’re only talking about a couple thousand [voters],” said Sanchez of UNM. “In a state like Florida, a couple thousand people can really make a difference in the election outcomes.”
Many also assume that the only valid proof is a driver’s license or state ID card. But Florida doesn’t have such strict rules. Election officials can accept a range of forms including public assistance identification, debit and credit cards, and gun licenses.
VoteRiders started its Florida campaign in June. So far, progress has been slow: they’ve worked with fifty people in the Orlando area to secure identification. Gallejo says the office receives more calls each week as the midterm elections approach.