History Repeats Itself for Native Americans - WhoWhatWhy

History Repeats Itself for Native Americans

Poster offering “Indian land” for sale. Photo credit: National Museum of the American Indian / YouTube
Reading Time: < 1 minute

While many Americans are outraged by the treatment of protesters fighting the construction of the Dakota Access Pipeline, those who have studied the history of Native Americans are hardly shocked. After all, there may not be a US policy as consistent as the mistreatment of the tribes who occupied the North American continent before the Europeans took over.

That policy can be summed up in five words: “Get out of the way!” When the white man wanted something, he would make sure that he got it — no matter the cost. In the end, it was always the indigenous people who paid the price.

Therefore, the acts of brutality perpetrated against the protesters should be viewed in a historical context. The shameful treatment they are experiencing right now is entirely consistent with what happened to the “savages” when they stood in the way of a white man trying to make a buck.

The following video shows that the attacks on the protesters is just the latest chapter in a string of injustices reaching back to the early days of the United States and beyond.

Related front page panorama photo credit: Adapted by WhoWhatWhy from Native Americans (National Museum of the American Indian / YouTube)

Where else do you see journalism of this quality and value?

Please help us do more. Make a tax-deductible contribution now.

Our Comment Policy

Keep it civilized, keep it relevant, keep it clear, keep it short. Please do not post links or promotional material. We reserve the right to edit and to delete comments where necessary.


31 responses to “History Repeats Itself for Native Americans”

  1. Avatar Cal says:

    So, Blackrobe…..where do you live? Did you happen to find that one slice of land on the North American continent where the indigenous peoples never wandered? You hypocrite! You think Canada treated the Indians any better? It may not have been wholesale slaughter, but there is blood, blame and shame on both sides of the border.

  2. Avatar KimberlyIswornout says:

    The pipeline is not on reservation land.

    • Avatar Jon says:

      Kimberly, I don’t think that’s the main issue to the people that are protesting the pipeline. If there is a burial ground where the pipeline may go, to many people burial grounds are sacred. Also, that pipeline will be crossing the Missouri. Like the video said, the US government used a lot of shady techniques to take native land. Do some research on Custer’s Black Hills Expedition.

    • Avatar KimberlyIswornout says:

      Under the Missouri. Right next to two pipelines already there. There are no burial grounds. The entire route was surveyed and adjusted to avoid culturally important sites.
      I’m Native American, fully aware of the history. Same history that has played out all across the world since the beginning of time.

    • Avatar Blackrobe says:

      All of the USA is on Indian land, America is built on the slaughter of indigenous people.

    • Avatar KimberlyIswornout says:

      We lost. The end.

    • Avatar KimberlyIswornout says:

      I’m indigenous people. Get over it.

  3. Avatar FiuToYou says:

    Whoever stands up against the ‘Standing Rock Water Protectors’, these are the people who should be thrown in jail. The sheriff of that county and his band of robot sadists should be in prison and Obama right along with them for doing nothing to help the true people of the land!!!