Israel: Settlers and the Two-State Solution

Make Hummus Not Walls, Bethlehem, Palestine
Reading Time: 3 minutes

One of the most controversial subjects under the sun is the dynamic between Israel and the Palestinians. There are many sides to this complex issue, and to help understand it better, we have chosen two short films that help explain it — mostly from the viewpoint of the Palestinians.

The videos show different aspects of the same tragic situation, innocent people on both sides being hurt in different ways every day — and for what?

The answer lies in the deep layers of grievances, perceptions, and opposing versions of history that serve as an infinite source of kindling, just waiting for the next spark.

The films we present show mostly the top layer, but they will give you a feel for what the atmosphere is really like. And although the first film — “Are Renegade Jewish Settlers Ruining the Two State Solution?” — was made in 2012, it shows something timeless, mysterious, and awful: how likable, seemingly rational people can have the most dangerous ideas.

The film was made by Simon Ostrovsky, winner of the 2016 DuPont Columbia University Award for Journalism. He is known for his coverage of the 2014 crisis in Ukraine for VICE News, and for “Selfie Soldiers,” an investigation he says he “carried out over several months in 2015 tracking a careless Russian soldier who was fighting in Ukraine and posting selfies in his spare time.” (Russia denies it ever sent any troops to Ukraine.)

Ostrovsky explained his interest in the West Bank — which was to be the future Palestinian state: “I wanted to find out who the settlers were, and what motivated them to pick up sticks and cross the Green Line to become the most notorious squatters the world has ever known.”

One settler, a man from South Africa, told him that he saw no reason why Palestinians should object to a Jewish presence in the West Bank. He claimed that Jews had been in the area for 5,000 years, whereas the Palestinians were only there as exiles from Israel for no more than two generations. Ostrovsky did not argue with him, but explained to the viewer:

This was an incredible fabrication… The notion that Palestinians had only lived on this land for two generations was totally false. But the idea that Jews had a historic claim to the West Bank‘s territories that trumped any Palestinian claims was one I hear over and over in the next few days and it turned out to be a major part of the settler ideology that ran directly counter to the two-state solution plan.

Another settler tells him,

In the Bible, it’s written for us: ‘You inherit it and you make it your home.’ And even then it says there will be a dispute over the land! So it’s known that there will always be a dispute over the land of Israel. Every nation wants to have their hold over this land.

Another example of why, to Ostrovsky, the situation may be hopeless. Yet the film is somehow upbeat.

Graffiti, Wall, Bethlehem, Palestine

Graffiti on wall in Bethlehem, Palestine. Photo credit: jordan pickett / Flickr (CC BY-NC 2.0)

Our second film “The Jewish Mothers Out to Stop Harassment of Palestinians” should restore your faith in people if you ever lost it. Courageous women, who call themselves “Machsom Watch,” monitor, and then report on, the way Israeli soldiers and police treat Palestinians at various checkpoints and borders.

And they do much more. Under the noses of the authorities, these women give comforting words, information on rights, food, water, and other small kindnesses, to those subjected to abuse by the authorities, such as three young men forced to stand in the heat, handcuffed and blindfolded, supposedly while their identities were being checked.

When night fell, one of the women discovered they were still being forced to stand. She made inquiries, and the bored guard said to her, “Go away and we’ll let them go.” He then roughly removed the handcuffs, releasing them finally — after nine hours — with no explanation for why they were detained. What would have happened had this Jewish woman not intervened?

One of the mothers explains their ultimate power:

Our strength is in our weakness. We come unguarded. We offer trust. We offer belief in people. We offer some kind of innocence. We want to bring it back to these tormented areas.

Video #1 

Are Renegade Jewish Settlers Ruining The Two State Solution?  (32:13)

Video #2

The Jewish Mothers Out to Stop Harassment of Palestinians (10:51)


Related front page panorama photo credit: Adapted by WhoWhatWhy from Harry Pockets / Flickr (CC BY-NC-SA 2.0).

Where else do you see journalism of this quality and value?

Please help us do more. Make a tax-deductible contribution now.

Our Comment Policy

Keep it civilized, keep it relevant, keep it clear, keep it short. Please do not post links or promotional material. We reserve the right to edit and to delete comments where necessary.

print

3 responses to “Israel: Settlers and the Two-State Solution”

  1. Every American should SEE the occupied territories courtesy of a first-hand look. I did so briefly in 1998 and was impressed with how bad it was. It is now much, much worse. Using the Bible to base one’s land claims (after all it was promised to US by God) is pretty crazy. But through lobbying efforts it has been widely sold.

  2. Roger Smith says:

    As an American, I would not go to South Africa during the apartheid era, as I felt that my presence would be a tacit form of approval for a policy that I knew to be immoral and, ultimately, ended. As an American Jew, I feel the same way about the present Israeli government’s policy regarding Jewish settlements on what was absolutely designated to be Arab land prior to the 1967 War.

    I applauded the Israeli victory in that war, but hardly could have imagined that, fifty years later, the IDF would be harshly occupying those lands. That the Netanyahu government uses specious threadbare historical analogies to justify this totally unwarranted occupation appalls me. That MY government supports all of the worst policies of Israel out of some craven calculation of the supposed political advantage of doing so appalls me to a still greater degree. But I know that Trump and Bibi will both end up despised by the people of their own countries and reviled by the opinion of the civilized world.

  3. RussLovesAmerica says:

    It is a sad state of affairs for the Palestinians in those countries surrounding Israel. These nations are Arab too, but they keep the Palestinians within their borders as 3rd class citizens. Why isn’t the Arab League or somebody seriously addressing this? So as long as the Palestinians are denied recognition in the “brother nations”, it would seem that they have no choice but to seek violence as a means of furthering their cause.