Will Meatless Burgers Save the World?

Impossible burger
Man eating an Impossible burger. Photo credit: Impossible Foods
Reading Time: 2 minutes

A petition asking the world’s largest fast-food chain to carry a meatless burger is gaining traction following its competitor’s successful trial of the “Impossible” burger. And — according to those who have eaten one — this meat replacement doesn’t actually taste like cardboard.

To some, there’s nothing more satisfying than sinking their teeth into a juicy beef burger. But the cattle industry is a large contributor to global-warming greenhouse gases — thanks to the carbon dioxide produced by cows, and the cutting down of forests, which soak up CO2, to make more room for grass-eating steers.

Other approaches to to lessening the environmental impact of humanity’s obsession with beef involve changing the diet of cattle and sucking up the CO2 in air treatment plants.

Attacking the problem on the consumer level, the recently introduced Impossible burger is the latest in a long line of meat substitutes. What’s new is the claim that instead of having to sacrifice taste for your principles, as with the vegan burgers of old, these new meatless burgers are tasty.

Burger King cleverly launched its meatless “Impossible” burger at 59 restaurants around St. Louis, MO, on April 1 — and according to those who have tried it, this breakthrough is no joke. The reactions from lifelong beef fans are priceless. As you can see in one of the videos below, they turn the air bleeping blue with their incredulity at the reveal that the burgers they just chomped aren’t 100 percent cow.

“We are making meat from plants,” said Impossible’s founder Pat Brown. “That’s never been done before. People have made plant-based replacements for meat, but they haven’t made plant-based meat.”

So. If it is and yet isn’t meat, just what in tarnation is it? And how is it tricking all these meat lovers into loving it like meat?

It’s all down to science. This meat substitute relies heavily on genetic modification — a phrase Impossible’s website doesn’t use, presumably to avert the negative reactions that usually follow. But while the company is trying to bury the actual science, it is extremely proud of the ingenuity its scientists employ to make veggies taste like burgers.

A protein called heme gives meat its taste, and Impossible has managed to replicate heme on an industrial scale to give its veggie burger that meaty taste. Root nodules of leguminous plants like soy contain leghemoglobin of which heme is a main component. But the quantity of nodules needed to replicate the flavor of beef had been prohibitive, so the food scientists at Impossible created heme through fermenting yeast. “It’s a far more scalable and sustainable way of making that protein,” says principal scientist Smita Shankar.

The patty used in the Burger King version models itself on the popular meat-to-fat ratio of 80/20 only the fat is coconut oil, and the meat is, well, not there.

Perhaps Burger King can persuade President Donald Trump to be a positive role model and swap his Big Mac for an Impossible burger. Or perhaps he will wait until McDonald’s brings out its version…

The videos this week are a quick explainer on the tasty franken-protein heme, a more in-depth look at the process Impossible uses to make its un-meat, and carnivores’ reactions to eating said plant-based burgers.

Related front page panorama photo credit:  Adapted by WhoWhatWhy from Impossible Foods.

Where else do you see journalism of this quality and value?

Please help us do more. Make a tax-deductible contribution now.

Our Comment Policy

Keep it civilized, keep it relevant, keep it clear, keep it short. Please do not post links or promotional material. We reserve the right to edit and to delete comments where necessary.


5 responses to “Will Meatless Burgers Save the World?”

  1. cfbcfb says:

    A lot of people are missing the problems with the “fake meat”.

    Its a highly, highly processed food.
    It uses ingredients not approved as safe for long term consumption.
    The teams working to get FDA approval are former tobacco lobbyists.
    It may take more energy/resources to produce than traditional beef.
    Its nutritionally not much better for you, in some cases it may be worse.
    Animals were fed this, killed and dissected.
    Not many vegans/vegetarians are going to walk into a place that primarily serves animal based products and eat a highly processed food product cooked on the same grill as meat.

    So the market for this IMO is a vegetarian/vegan who really like eating beef and will be satisfied with a highly processed product that tastes nearly the same served up by a burger chain that kills millions of cows and chickens every year. At least once you understand the FULL truth of it.

  2. L says:

    Although this is interesting, as a vegetarian, I would not want to eat something that had the look and texture of a beef burger even if it was plant based.

  3. Binker says:

    I’m an American living in Taiwan. Buddhism and vegetarian food are big over here, and vegetable meat substitutes (foods made from vegetables and mushrooms that seem like meat) are common. Just yesterday I had a meatless burger my wife made from this stuff, and wondered why MacDonald’s can’t offer something like that. So it’s a coincidence for me to see this article today.
    I notice that Ms. Vitarelli, and apparently Who What Why as a whole, accept the notion of “anthropomorphic climate change,” so the following comments probably will be unwelcome. That is something I bailed on years ago upon hearing much evidence to the contrary, and I would suggest that interested persons check this out. One good summary can be found in an interview with F. William Engdahl, “Myths, Lies, Oil and Climate Wars.” Other information can be found among the Thunderbolt Project’s You Tube videos.

  4. Dave Lewis says:

    I tried one, and it’s tasty. Been a long time since I had a Whopper , so it’s a bit hard to compare.

    I was the first hourly employees of BK when it came to St. Louis. Whoppers were 36 cents then (1965). It’s hard for me to pay $5 for a burger, even a good one.

  5. MacKenzie says:

    For those interested in plant-based meat, the “Beyond Burger” is non-GMO (though I’m not sure that it would be considered “healthy”).