Exhumation Proves Murder of Brazilian President, New York Times Must Admit

Reading Time: 4 minutes
Murdered after all.

Murdered after all.

A few weeks ago, we ran a piece criticizing a subtly deceptive article in the New York Times that made light of a wave of exhumations of popular leftist figures in Latin America. Quoting unnamed “scholars,” the paper’s Latin American correspondent Simon Romero suggested the forensic digs

may be the secularized continuation of customs from the time of early Christianity, when a vibrant trade involved the body parts of saints.

That, in fact, is nonsense.  The purportedly “natural”, “accidental”, or “suicide-related” deaths of such important left-leaning figures as Nobel Laureate Pablo Neruda, Brazil’s President Joao Goulart and Chile’s President Salvador Allende all occurred during the rule of various rightist dictators.

The re-examination of evidence in these cases is based therefore on strong skepticism about the “official” narratives of their deaths.  This skepticism, in turn, is based on a well-documented history of thousands of cases of political murder in the region.

Far from looking for relics to sell, investigators are looking for evidence that these deaths were actually assassinations, the work of fearful tyrants anxious to prevent the victims’ return to power.  Now one result is in, and it’s explosive.

Truth Commission: Juscelino Kubitschek Assassinated

Investigators from Brazil’s Truth Commission, looking into the 1976 car crash of former leftist Brazilian president Juscelino Kubitschek and his limo driver, have discovered a bullet fragment lodged in the driver’s skull. This finding, the Commission ruled, along with other evidence, suggests that Kubitschek was murdered—most likely at the behest of the leaders of the CIA-backed military coup that also ousted his successor Joao Goulart.

Kubitschek himself at the wheel. (Photo by Antonio Lucio/AE)

Kubitschek himself at the wheel. (Photo by Antonio Lucio/AE)

What Romero Did Not Report: U.S. Involvement

Romero himself reported this new inquest finding on December 10 in a short article datelined Santiago (“Brazilian Panel Says Ex-Leader Was Murdered”). Romero noted that at the time of Kubitschek’s death, Brazil was ruled by a junta, but as in the case of his earlier article on exhumations, he very significantly chose not to mention the role of the CIA in bringing Brazil’s junta to power.

In his newer, more soberly reported article, Romero nonetheless still failed to mention Operation Condor. That was a coordinated effort by dictatorships in Latin American countries, to track down and kill political opponents in their various countries—an effort that was deliberately aided, particularly during the mid-to-late ‘70s, by the CIA. (See our original piece on this subject for more background.)

The Agency, while perhaps not directing the killings—and which in any case has a history of carefully avoiding a direct evidentiary trail of involvement in covert operations—did enable the building of a crucial database on leftist activists and ousted leaders, and facilitated radio communications among the various countries’ intelligence services.

As Columbia Journalism School professor John Dinges, author of The Condor Years (The New Press, 2004) explains in an interview with WhoWhatWhy,

The CIA in Condor didn’t orchestrate the killing of leaders and activists. They didn’t have to do that; the Latin Americans were doing that on their own. What the CIA did was provide assistance, like computers for maintaining data banks.


That distinction may not mollify Latin Americans who are looking for the truth about the real roots of democracy’s historic collapse in their countries in the 1970s and 1980s.


Additional untimely deaths in Latin America are likely to be reclassified as political murders in the coming months.

While autopsies are not always definitive, forensic studies are becoming more sophisticated. They’re also becoming more popular in a region where the political pendulum has decisively swung in recent years from right to left, with more left-leaning governments being elected in the region— including in Brazil, Uruguay, Bolivia, Ecuador, Peru, Venezuela, and most recently Chile, where Socialist Michelle Bachelet won a landslide victory in regaining the presidency there.

Those leaders, for obvious reasons, will wants answers to the grim fate of similar leaders who came before them.  Currently, for example, the Argentine Forensic Anthropology Team is working to identify victims of that country’s “dirty war” against leftists.

One case to watch carefully is that of Brazilian President Goulart, whose body was exhumed last month. Goulart, who died in exile in Argentina nine months after a junta overthrew his elected government, was officially reported to have suffered a heart attack. But as his death came at the height of Operation Condor, with dictators aiding each other in eliminating their exiled opponents, there has always been speculation that Goulart had actually been murdered.

A former Uruguayan intelligence officer, himself in trouble on other charges, publicly testified a few years back that Goulart was poisoned by Uruguayan operatives at the request of the Brazilian junta. Tissue samples are being sent to Europe for testing.

What Romero Did Not Report: Amnesty Laws can be Overturned

In his recent article, the Times’s Romero noted that in 1979 Brazil passed an amnesty law, which he said makes any prosecution in these cases impossible.

What he did not report, notably, is that amnesty laws can be overturned—as was done in Chile. This allowed the prosecution of the dictator and coup leader Augusto Pinochet Ugarte and others.  There is a campaign in Brazil to do the same, and the finding that Kubitschek, one of the country’s most celebrated presidents, was murdered, could give it an added boost.

[box]WhoWhatWhy plans to continue doing this kind of groundbreaking original reporting. You can count on it. But can we count on you? We cannot do our work without your support.

Please click here to donate; it’s tax deductible. And it packs a punch.[/box]

IMAGE: Time Cover

IMAGE: Kubitschek in car

IMAGE: Condor Years

Where else do you see journalism of this quality and value?

Please help us do more. Make a tax-deductible contribution now.

Our Comment Policy

Keep it civilized, keep it relevant, keep it clear, keep it short. Please do not post links or promotional material. We reserve the right to edit and to delete comments where necessary.


11 responses to “Exhumation Proves Murder of Brazilian President, New York Times Must Admit”

  1. Title

    […]although web-sites we backlink to below are considerably not connected to ours, we really feel they may be really really worth a go by means of, so have a look[…]

  2. jose says:

    How about the latest batch of Latin leaders who have come down with cancer? What I would like to know is did Oliver Stone give Chavez a box of chocolates?

    • Hollywood Mark says:

      That’s really a cheap shot. No one was bigger fan of Chavez than Stone. No one in American culture other than Penn took more heat for it. Two documentaries on Chavez by Stone. Really? Why would you smear Stone’s name?

  3. Archie1954 says:

    When and if they actually do investigate such politicians’ deaths they will find the CIA, the proxy for the US government behind the murders as always. Just check back to see what murderous old fool was occupying the oval office at the time and you will have the mafia kingpin of international criminality for all to see.

  4. Nothing will ever change. If the USgov has any part, even if its someone serving coffee to a political figure they are not found of, they will be the one inevitably responsible for rape, oppression, torture, genocide, and war. We have our very own school that has a laundry list of past students who are terrorist in countries the USgov just can’t seem to get along with. Im sure most know who I’m talking bout, if not go to: http://soaw.org/ Now of course SOA changed their name, as most do that want to put a pretty face one their publically disgraced, USGov funded murderes, like “Blackwater” changed theirs, there are even folks in UScongress trying to rename the slave trade to some “trilateral” capitalist movement. However, Americans aren’t so lucky. The USgov has sealed the fate of the American people. Sept 11th 2001 destroyed not only lives but our Constitution. Though our political leaders (I know we elect them they shouldnt be called that, but seriously, does anyone actually think they work for us) have always pushed the boundaries, breaking laws when they can, the Patriot Act made it all legal and those folks immune from any accountability. So, we will always be known as Americans and the USA. There is no way to put a pretty mask on, change our name to try and trick the world into thinking our government is the largest terrorist organization ever known to mankind. The chickens will come hope to roost, and you better pray to a god that your dead before that happens!

  5. Chris Herz says:

    I would not put any crime past the CIA and its political masters. The sine qua non for any of these countries is to drive out the US.

    • fogspider says:

      and corporate masters. political, corporate…essentially the same thing, now. inextricably entwined.

  6. F. G. Sanford says:

    A similar exhumation of Kennedy would likely find not just a bullet fragment, but an entire bullet somewhere in the thoracic cavity. The throat and back wounds were both of the entrance variety. Unless they dissected his chest on autopsy, the bullet that entered his back is still in there. An x-ray would put the whole thing to rest.

  7. Tania says:

    There is a telephone call between CIA agentes and Lindon Johnson famous for exposing the very DIRECT role of CIA

  8. Howie Klein says:

    A couple of hours ago I was at La Capella del Hombre in Quito, unable to keep myself from crying in front of a painting by Guayasamin dedicated to the memory and struggle of Allende, Neruda and Jara, three heroes of liberation murdered at the behest of my own country.