Shrinks Who Dare to Label Trumpism as a Mental Health Issue - WhoWhatWhy Shrinks Who Dare to Label Trumpism as a Mental Health Issue - WhoWhatWhy

Science

Donald Trump, shakes hands, Mark Milley
Donald Trump and Mark Milley at Trump's Inaugural Parade in 2017. Photo credit: US Army / Wikimedia (PD)

A sobering article by Forbes investigative journalist Richard Behar — summarized.

Listen To This Story
Voiced by Amazon Polly

There’s a forensic psychiatrist at Harvard who argues that the deeply dangerous behavior of Donald Trump and his MAGA followers can best be understood — and combatted — as a national mental-health crisis. 

Dr. Bandy X. Lee, a faculty member in Harvard’s Program in Psychiatry and the Law, minces no words in labeling Trump a pathological liar:

The effect of pathological lying … is to inundate public discourse until … truth no longer matters, the public is “gaslit” to disorientation, and his audience conditioned to accept fantastical assertions that are no longer tethered to reality.

Lee has a few critics in psychiatric circles; they claim she violates a principle of her specialty, or skirts too close to the line, by diagnosing a public figure whom she has never privately interviewed as a patient. Lee says she does not do that (and ‘pathological liar’ is not an official diagnosis in the field’s manual).

Moreover, to Lee, and the many psychiatrists and other professionals who take her side, silence is not an option with the fate of the nation at stake. “No one with Donald Trump’s impairments,” she says, ”would be hired by a private corporation or by the military, the police, or the government civil service.”

For a thoroughly reported and closely reasoned story on this issue, look to Richard Behar, a much-acclaimed investigative journalist for Forbes — “Trump, Madoff, And The Art (And Science) Of Pathological Lying.”

Mark Milley
Former Chairman, Joint Chiefs of Staff Mark Milley, holding Dr. Bandy Lee’s book ‘The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump: 27 Psychiatrists and Mental Health Experts Assess A President,’ Washington, DC, June 2024. Photo by Mark Bruzonsky; Courtesy Richard Behar/Forbes

To put the Trump phenomenon in perspective, Behar brackets the former president with Bernie Madoff, the progenitor of the biggest Ponzi scheme in history, the $68 billion scam that fooled hundreds of otherwise intelligent people — for nearly a half-century, as Behar reveals in his recent book, Madoff: The Final Word.

Once you see Trump — with Behar’s guidance and Lee’s professional insights — as a preternaturally gifted con artist, a malign master of hiding his self-serving flimflammery behind the distracting rhetoric of a snake-oil salesman, you cannot unsee it.

As for Lee’s credentials in the field of political prognostication (she also spent 25 years treating violent criminals in prisons), Behar offers this quote:

I predicted in my 2020 book [Profile of a Nation: Trump’s Mind, America’s Soul] that his fragile psychology would not be able to tolerate an election loss, that violence would result, and that his “presidency” would not end for his followers. 

In the aftermath of the January 6, 2021, insurrection at the Capitol, veteran journalist Bill Moyers, a White House press secretary under LBJ, called Lee “the least surprised person in the country.” 

Donald Trump, model, Television City, 1985
Donald Trump in late 1985 with a model of “Television City,” a development proposal for the former West Side Yard, now Riverside South. Photo credit: Bernard Gotfryd / Wikimedia (PD)

Author

  • Gerald Jonas

    Gerald Jonas is a senior editor at WhoWhatWhy and a writer whose work has appeared in The New Yorker and The New York Times, as well as other journals large and small.

    View all posts

Comments are closed.