And his pattern of dodging payment and legal manipulation is instructive.
|
Listen To This Story
 |
Donald Trump has long styled himself as a high-stakes, deal-making mogul — a man who wins bigly, walks away clean, and leaves everyone else holding the bag.
But behind that gilded image lies a four decades-long pattern of evasions, delays, unpaid debts, and opaque settlements.
Since the 1970s, Trump has been embroiled in 4,095 cases, so far, — including this selection of cases, described as his “greatest hits.” The most consistent thread? Trump almost never pays, at least not publicly.
By the time he was elected president in 2016, Trump had accumulated more legal actions than any elected official in US history, many of which are continuing through his presidency.
Whether it’s dodging bills, stiffing his lawyers, pulling them into legal jeopardy, settling lawsuits in secret, or disparaging and manipulating the slow grind of the US legal system, Trump’s playbook is designed to bury costs and erase any trace of responsibility.
Trump doesn’t just delay justice — he undermines it. By refusing to pay legal teams, he forces lawyers to sue or risk their reputations. His strategy? Endless delays, appeals, and settlements when the spotlight fades, leaving a trail of unpaid judgments and sanctions
Four Recent Cases Where Trump Lost — and Has Not Paid
Civil Fraud in New York — $478 Million Judgment: In February 2024, a New York judge ruled that Trump had systematically inflated the value of his assets to secure loans and boost his net worth. The penalty: $478 million and a three-year ban from operating a business in New York — yet he continues to delay payment through appeals and bonding tactics.
Defamation Lawsuits by E. Jean Carroll — $88.3 Million Judgment: After denying Carroll’s rape accusation and defaming her while in office, Trump was ordered to pay $83.3 million — on top of a $5 million judgment from a previous trial. Despite the rulings, Trump labeled the judgments as “pending appeal,” and they remain unpaid as of his most recent financial disclosures.
Frivolous Lawsuit Against Hillary Clinton — Nearly $1 Million Sanction: A federal judge sanctioned Trump and his legal team $937,989.39 for filing a baseless lawsuit against Hillary Clinton and others. The judge accused Trump of “undermining the rule of law” through lawsuits meant only to “air political grievances.”
Lawsuit Against The New York Times – $400,000 Legal Fee Order: After suing The New York Times over a Pulitzer-winning story on his family’s taxes, Trump lost and was ordered to pay nearly $400,000 in legal fees. The court dismissed the case, citing constitutional protections for journalists.
Trump Lost and Did Pay, Publicly, in These 3 Cases
Trump University Settlement — $25 Million: Settled a class-action suit for fraud, where students claimed they were misled by Trump’s fake college.
Trump Foundation Shutdown — $2 Million: New York state forced the Trump Foundation to dissolve after finding it engaged in illegal political activity and self-dealing.
Trump Miami Resort Overtime Lawsuit – $34,863: A lawsuit filed by 48 workers at Trump National Doral Miami over unpaid overtime.
Trump’s Favorite Move: Settle and Silence
Trump settles cases he can’t win to hide payment amounts, protect his brand, and avoid accountability. Given Trump’s well documented history of using threats, delays, and NDAs to control settlements, it’s likely he pressures individuals into signing NDAs with the threat of dragging out cases for years. Here’s a typical example
Racial Discrimination on The Apprentice — Confidential Settlement: Former contestants accused Trump of discrimination and unpaid work. The settlement was sealed, with reports suggesting payouts in the millions.
The apparent only exception to this silence was Omarosa Manigault-Newman (2018). Omarosa revealed she received a $1.3 million settlement and spoke about it as part of her book tour.
A System Exploited, Not Broken — Yet
Trump’s Tax Evasion Investigations (Ongoing): Investigations into Trump’s taxes, including the New York state probe, reveal his use of offshore entities, complex financial tools, and possible fraud to avoid liabilities.
Trump Organization’s Business Practices: Beyond fraud, probes into the Trump Organization show misuse of tax deductions and inflated asset values, turning his business into a shield and tool for evasion.
Trump’s ability to delay, evade, and manipulate the legal system raises critical questions about its effectiveness in holding public figures accountable.
The real issue is not whether Trump will eventually pay for his actions — but whether the system will be reformed to prevent public figures like him from gaming the system indefinitely.
